Butt Plug Materials

Posted by Anna Bergeron on

An anal plug is used both to prepare the anal muscles for sex and to add a little erotic stimulation to your love life. If you’re looking for the perfect plug for your needs, you’ll want to pay attention to all aspects of each plug that you’re considering.

This includes the shape, size, design, and, of course, the material that the toy is made of. If you’re researching butt plugs and feel a little overwhelmed, do not worry.

While it is true that there are many types of materials for butt plugs, your decision as to which one to choose can be much easier to make once you learn a little about each of these materials.


Much as with other sex toys such as dildos and vibrators, butt plugs can be made out of many different materials, each with its own pros and cons. In the end, however, your own personal preferences and tastes will help you choose the butt plug that is right for you.

Things such as the price, the overall safety of the toy, how it feels once it’s inside of you, and how easy it is to clean the toy are all important things to look at when you’re shopping for butt plugs and the material they are made out of will affect each of these.

There are many different materials for butt plugs because there are many different users out there and everybody has his or her own likes and dislikes when it comes to sex toys. In order to accommodate everybody, sex toy companies make their toys out of a lot of different materials.

Keep in mind, however, that all sex toys are strictly regulated so as long as you’re purchasing your butt plugs from a reputable toy store and a reputable manufacturer, you will never have to worry about the products being unsafe or dangerous for you.

Knowing the facts about each and every material also helps; below are some tips that you should keep in mind when you’re shopping for butt plugs.


A lot of sex toys are made out of silicone and there is little wonder why. Silicone is less expensive than some other high-end materials, is hypoallergenic, and offers the perfect combination of softness and firmness.

Butt plugs made out of silicone also keep their shape very easily, which means that you can use them for a very long time without worrying about them becoming misshapen and therefore not doing their job properly.

Silicone butt plugs are also non-porous, which means that they won’t gather bacteria, dust mites, and dirt, which might cause you to get an infection that you don’t want.

Silicone butt plugs can also come in various colors so whether you want a butt plug that is pink, purple, or blue, you can usually find one made of silicone that comes in that color. They can also bend just the right amount regardless of what type of play you prefer and they will never scrape or chafe your skin

They are comfortable yet accommodating regardless of how kinky you get in the bedroom. You don’t have to worry about sitting the wrong way and having a silicone butt plug poke you in the colon or become uncomfortable for you.


Silicone butt plugs are very comfortable and come in so many price ranges that everyone can find one that he or she can afford. They are often recommended for beginners because they are smooth and soft, not to mention easy to handle.

They are simple to use and it will never take you a long time to get used to the feel of a silicone butt plug. If you want a butt plug that is easy to clean, extremely comfortable, and very reasonably priced, silicone butt plugs are what you should purchase.


Just as with other types of butt plugs, the ones made out of silicone have their disadvantages as well as their advantages. Although they are smooth, they are not the smoothest type of butt plug and they can even occasionally be a bit on the bumpy side, although none of them are extremely bumpy.

In addition, if you’re interested in sterilizing your silicone butt plug, it is possible but very difficult. This means that if you’re planning on sharing a butt plug with someone else, which normally isn’t recommended anyway, this is not the type of butt plug that you want.

Finally, silicone butt plugs require the use of water-based lube only because silicone-based lube doesn’t work on them. This is a disadvantage to many people because a lot of people only have water-based lube in their collection.

How Does it Feel?

Silicone butt plugs are comfortable and easy to use because they are so smooth and soft so inserting them is fast and simple. Their comfort comes from the fact that they are flexible with just the right amount of firmness, which are but a few of the many reasons why they are often recommended for beginners.


Stainless steel butt plugs are usually nickel-free and are actually some type of surgical steel or other metal, which means that this type of butt plug is one of the hardest types of butt plugs on the market, if not the hardest overall.

For those users who love extra-hard butt plugs that will never bend, stretch, or become misshapen, the metal butt plugs are the way to go. Stainless steel butt plugs are extremely smooth, very simple to clean, and easily sterilized and they have a durability that is second to none.

In fact, it is very possible that you will be able to keep your stainless steel butt plug for a lifetime.

Butt plugs made out of stainless steel will easily enter the anal cavity, making your anal playtime very comfortable and erotic. They are nearly impossible to break and once you find the right spot to apply some pressure, they will never let you down because they keep their shape regardless of what you do to them.

In addition, stainless steel butt plugs simply look fantastic and their attractiveness is one of the reasons why so many people choose this type of butt plug.


One of the many advantages of using stainless steel butt plugs is that they are great for people who want to add a little warmth or coolness to their sexual activities. You can place them in the freezer or heat them up before you insert them and they will remain at that temperature for a very long time.

This characteristic also makes them very easy to clean and to sterilize because you can even boil them in water if you like. Finally, stainless steel butt plugs enable you to have explosive orgasms every time, thanks to the unique way that they feel once they’re inside of you.


For beginners, stainless steel butt plugs are not recommended simply because of their inflexibility, which can make them a bit uncomfortable if you are not used to butt plugs. In fact, because they do not twist or bend, you can actually damage your colon if you’re inexperienced and try to use stainless steel butt plugs.

This is why only experienced users should use any type of metal butt plug but there is another disadvantage as well. People who like to wear their butt plugs or sleep in them should not use stainless steel butt plugs so avoid this type of butt plug if this is what you want to do.

How Does it Feel?

The firmness of stainless steel butt plugs is what many people love about them but it is also what some people dislike about them.

Once again, metal butt plugs should only be used by people who are already experienced with this type of sex toy because in most cases, they are simply too hard and inflexible for those just beginning the practice.


Glass butt plugs offer many advantages and as with metal toys, these butt plugs are hard and very sturdy. If you’ve never before used a glass butt plug and you’re a bit apprehensive about it, there is no need to be concerned.

The glass that these toys are made out of is a very thick, processed type of glass that is extremely difficult to shatter, break, or even chip

If you choose this type of butt plug, you should definitely inspect it as soon as you open the original package but if it is nice and smooth as it should be at that point, the chances of it breaking in the future are very slim indeed.

Butt plugs made out of glass also have the advantage of looking great because these types of butt plugs come in various colors and designs so they can be quite the head-turner.

In addition to solid colors, glass butt plugs can also be decorative in nature so if you want a butt plug that does its job and has a special beauty and visual appeal, these are the type of butt plugs that you want.


Glass butt plugs are great for both beginners and experienced users because they are harder than silicone plugs but not as hard as stainless steel plugs. They are also transparent, which makes inserting them into your lover’s anal canal an exciting thing to do.

Glass butt plugs are super easy to clean and very smooth, making them extremely comfortable, and even beginners can get used to them very quickly.


One of the biggest disadvantages of choosing a glass butt plug is that even though breakage is unlikely, it does still occasionally happen.

You’ll need to be extra careful with your glass butt plug so that you don’t drop it, which means that it needs a little more attention than other types of butt plugs. Glass butt plugs can also be a little on the pricey side so if you choose this type of butt plug, be prepared to pay a little extra for it.

How Does it Feel?

Fortunately, glass butt plugs are extremely comfortable; in fact, many people simply will not use any other type of butt plug once they get used to the glass ones. These plugs are very smooth and soft and because they are between silicone and metal butt plugs when it comes to their firmness, they usually feel fantastic once they’re inside of you.


At one time, butt plugs and other sex toys were frequently made out of jelly or many types of rubber but that has changed these days. This is because jelly and rubber can contain chemicals that we now know can be dangerous to use.

Phthalates, for example, are a chemical that is added to many types of rubber but is now known to cause a host of medical problems, including serious ones such as cancer and even damaged reproductive organs.

If you check your sex toy and it says that it is “phthalates-free,” this is the one that you should purchase.

Of course, there are still rubber and jelly types of butt plugs on the market, although they are rare. Their two main advantages are their price, which is always extremely low, and their softness, which gives them a tremendous amount of flexibility.

However, most sex toy experts now recommend that you switch from rubber or jelly sex toys to toys made out of silicone or metal, just to be on the safe side. After all, price and softness are no substitute for good health so opting for the safer toys is always your best bet.


The only real advantages of rubber or jelly butt plugs are the low price and the flexibility; the latter makes it a great sex toy for beginners.

They are not as firm as silicone, which also has a certain amount of flexibility, and they may be too soft to maneuver effectively in some cases. Once again, these types of butt plugs are generally no longer recommended.


Phthalates aren’t the only chemical known to be found in rubber and jelly sex toys as other harmful chemicals are also found in many of them.

In addition to negative side effects, they are generally poorly made and are often not that comfortable, which is yet another reason not to use these types of butt plugs.

How Does it Feel?

Overall, the consensus seems to be that jelly and rubber butt plugs aren’t that comfortable, usually because they are too soft to be used correctly.

Even if you do find one that is comfortable to use, you’ll still have to be concerned about the toy being unsafe and even dangerous for you.

Rather than using a cheap, overly soft rubber or jelly butt plug, you might as well spend a little bit more and get a toy that is both comfortable and safe for you to use.


Believe it or not, there are numerous other materials used in the making of butt plugs, including wood, plastic, and even gold and silver.

In fact, nowadays there are crafters who make super-expensive butt plugs for the wealthy and, as you can imagine, it is a very lucrative business.

Wood and other materials are often polished so that the toy is extra smooth and soft. Sometimes they are even coated with a material that makes them even more comfortable and attractive. Indeed, some of these sex toys cost up to $2000 or more!

Of course, just because these types of butt plugs are so expensive doesn’t mean they are necessarily better than the rest of them. It simply means they are made out of materials that are a lot more expensive to begin with, which is why their final costs are so high.

Unless you fit into the “super-wealthy” category, you might as well save your money for something else.

Sex toys simply don’t have to be expensive to be effective and enjoyable, which is a good thing since the majority of both men and women now have sex toys in their homes.


The type of material you should choose for your butt plug depends largely on your experience level. If you’re new to anal sexual activity, you might want to try a softer material such as silicone; however, if you’re more experienced, you can choose just about anything.

In fact, some experienced users stick with silicone because they love the way that it feels while many others want to “graduate” to something a little harder, such as stainless steel or glass. The choice is really based more on personal preferences than anything else.

Fortunately, most sex toys -- including butt plugs -- are very reasonably priced. This means that if you try one butt plug and you dislike it for whatever reason, you won’t have wasted too much money on it and can therefore move onto another type.

Butt plug preferences are very personalized and vary greatly from user to user but since there are so many of them now on the market, you should have no trouble finding the one that is best for you, especially if you consider all of the pros and cons of each of them.

← Older Post Newer Post →

You Might Also Be Interested In:

Butt Plug: Frequently Asked Questions

What is a butt plug? It is an extremely popular sex toy which is used for anal play. It typically takes the form of a short, rounded knob with a flared base for easy removal and insertion. However...

Read More

Wearing A Butt Plug in public

These are used for a variety of purposes. These include: To relax and stretch out the anal muscles so that anal sex is more comfortable To provide a little foreplay before any type of anal sexual...

Read More

10 Best Homemade Butt Plugs

Many people are do-it-yourself enthusiasts, but is the DIY method good enough for your plug? If you want to be safe – and who doesn’t? – it is best to purchase one that is made by a reputable sex ...

Read More

Male Butt Plug: Does Using One Make You Gay?

These are not exactly new but their popularity has really taken off in recent years. Contrary to what many people believe, anal sex toys are not just for gay men anymore.

Read More

Anal Training and Stretching with A Butt Plug

If you intend to use a plug to stretch those ass muscles out so that anal sex is a little more comfortable, one of the best ways to do this is by using this toy.

Read More

Cleaning Your Butt Plug

A butt plug is a very popular sex toy for both men and women as well as both gay and straight people.

Read More

How Long Can You Leave a Butt Plug in?

For many people, wearing a plug for long periods of time is the norm, but for people who have never done this before, it might seem like a peculiar thing to do. People keep a plug inserted for man...

Read More

Butt Plug and Sex

These toys are a great way to intensify your sexual pleasure because they stimulate those sensitive nerve endings in the anus that you have been ignoring all these years.

Read More

What Does a Butt Plug Feel Like?

If you are one of these people who cannot do without their plug, you have a lot more company than you think.

Read More

Butt Plug Materials

A butt plug is used both to prepare the anal muscles for sex and to add a little erotic stimulation to your love life. If you’re looking for the perfect plug for your needs, you’ll want to pay att...

Read More